Improving Your Google Rankings Without Getting Penalized

Everyone wants to achieve better search engine rankings. That’s because organic search traffic is a proven driver of business growth.

The only trouble is, SEO keeps changing and no-one wants a penalty because of doing the wrong thing in trying to improve search engine ranking.

Google has been rolling out updates, ranging from Panda to Penguin to Google EMDs (exact match domain names), the (PBN) Private Blog Network deindexing updates, and most recently, Hummingbird.

If you’re concerned about getting targeted traffic without incurring penalties, then this article is for you.

It’s important to know that the most recent Google updates are based on Google’s mission statement:

Google’s mission is to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful.

To rank well, your content needs to align with that mission.

That’s why I’m going back to basics with on-page SEO to help you understand the new SEO rules, learn how to optimize for both humans and search algorithm robots, and to master on-page and off-page optimization.

This in-depth guide will walk you through the steps that you need to take in order to optimize and improve your Google search engine rankings so that you can generate more organic traffic to your website without getting penalized.

Here’s a breakdown of the topics I’ll cover:

  1. Assess your current search engine ranking
  2. Track the right metrics
  3. Diagnose and analyze penalties
  4. Do keyword research
  5. Go after your keywords with great content
  6. Build links the right way

Learn how I grew my search traffic by 51% in 3 months by following the steps described in this blog post.


Step #1: Assess Your Current Search Ranking

Before you can improve your site’s search ranking, its fundamental to know your current position in the Google search results. This is crucial, even if your site is new. There are several tools and resources that can give you this information.

Use to check your site’s keyword rank: If you have been targeting specific keywords in page content, use to assess your rank. Type in your keyword (I used “content marketing” in this example) and your site URL.

The results page will show where your site ranks in search engines for the term, as well as the first page on your site that comes up in search results for the topic.

Check your site speed: Next, it’s important to check site speed, as this is a major Google ranking factor.

If your site is slow, you have little chance of a high search position and it will affect your chances of making sales, too.

According to WebPerformanceToday, Walmart experienced a sharp decline in conversions when its page load times increased from 1 to 4 seconds.

If this happens, it doesn’t matter what your on-page SEO, meta description or any title tags are. The search algorithm will punish you, even if you are a giant like Walmart.

That’s why it’s important to run your own site speed test to figure out how to improve Google rankings. There are dozens of tools that can help you do this. Some of my favorites are:

Here’s how to test your page content speed with Pingdom.

Go to and type in your URL. Press the “Test Now” button and wait for the results to load.

Ideally, you want your site’s performance level to be as high as possible. Quick Sprout registers a performance grade of 71. As long as your site registers over 50, that’s a good start.

If you get a performance grade of less than 50, your page content is really slow and you need to work on improving it.

Check the page load time, too.

Quick Sprout is a little high, at more than 3 seconds. Aim for under 2 seconds for a really fast site and under 1 second for mobile devices. According to research cited by eConsultancy, 47% of Americans expect page content to load in under 2 seconds.

Check site health: After looking at keyword search engine rank and site speed, assess the health of your site before you start to optimize.

Have you experienced a sudden drop in organic traffic after months or years of consistency? Are you wondering whether Google has deindexed (or banned) your site?

Are you wondering whether Google has deindexed (or banned) your site?

If you want to know for sure, use PixelGroove’s Google penalty checker tool. Input your URL and click “Check!”

If everything looks fine, you’ll soon get a message.

If it doesn’t, the tips in this article will help you to recover your Google search engine ranking.

Another aspect of site health to search engines is domain age. While Matt Cutts said in this video that “the difference between a six-month-old domain and a one-year-old domain name is not huge at all,” that doesn’t mean it’s irrelevant.

Search algorithms will still see it.

SerpIQ analyzed over 160,000 SERPs (search engine results pages) and 1.6 million URLs and concluded that domain age contributed to #1 rankings for the majority of the domain names in their study:

This also means that you need to be patient. As your domain ages and the links pointing to your site age, your search engine ranking should increase.

Step #2: Track the Right Metrics

Next, it’s time to track some vital metrics for your site, to find out what other factors you need to improve. Here are the most important metrics to assess.

Organic traffic: It’s important to know how many visitors find your site via Google. It’s a great way to assess its effectiveness. A chart published on Business2Community shows that 52% of Hubspot’s leads, in 2012, came from search engines. Hubspot’s chart also shows the importance of on-page SEO in lead conversion.

To find out how many visitors reach your site, log in to your Google Analytics account and check out the acquisition channels report. This helpful Google Analytics video tutorial will guide you.

Organic traffic conversions: As well as analyzing your search traffic, it’s worth paying attention to the keywords that generate traffic for your site.

One way to find these is with a tool called Serp Scan. I’ve been using it to identify the keywords that convert organically for my site. One reason I recommend it is because it’s simple to use.

Serp Scan will show you the keywords that have sent organic traffic to your site within the last 12 months. It includes an on-page SEO keyword performance chart.

This tool makes it easy to get the data that you need from Google Analytics and to understand the broad picture relating to keywords on your site. But, you still need more.


Keyword ranking for commercial keywords: According to Brian Dean, the #1 keyword research mistake is not spending enough time on commercial keywords. That’s because commercial keywords are the ones that make money.


That’s because commercial keywords are the ones that make money. To improve your search engine rank and make money, you need to understand the difference between commercial and informational keywords to improve Google rankings.

If all of your keywords are informational, you will still generate organic traffic, but converting those visitors to buyers or people who share on social media may be difficult.

The reason is because visitors who search for informational keywords like:

  • how to clear acne with home products
  • how to install WordPress
  • make money online for free
  • free ebook download
  • top 10 free article spinners

If they are not in a buying mood, they want you to speak their language – the search engines language of free.

In contrast, people who use keywords like:

  • best acne products
  • top 10 web hosting providers
  • web designers in NY

are probably searching for a solution that they can buy.

If you’re in the e-commerce industry, you will hopefully already know that commercial keywords tend to convert well.

Keywords that have the words below as a prefix (before) or suffix (after) to the rest of the keyword phrase tend to do well:

  • Buy
  • Review
  • Purchase
  • Discount
  • Coupon
  • Deal
  • Shipping
  • Order

Earlier, I talked about the keywords that are sending you organic traffic. They should also be used in the meta description as well as the on-page SEO. Here’s another example. Can you spot the difference between informational and commercial keywords?

Set up an SEO dashboard to track these metrics: I recommend that you set up an SEO dashboard so that you can track all of the important metrics at any time.

Here’s one example, from

In addition to setting up dashboards in Google Analytics, you can get even richer keyword data by connecting Google Webmaster Tools to Google Analytics. Here’s a step-by-step guide from

Step #3: Diagnose and Analyze Penalties


Now that you understand your search ranking and have set up tracking for the most important metrics, it’s time to examine your site in detail to see if there are any penalties in effect.


This is fundamental because there is no point in promoting or building links to an unhealthy site.

How link building has changed: Up until 2012, spammy links improved search engine rankings for thousands of people. This Moz case study shows how one site used link schemes to build inbound links.

But, recent Google updates change search algorithm patterns to make sure that link schemes don’t work anymore.

Regardless of on-page SEO, bad links hurt you. Use them and you will incur a penalty rather than working to improve Google rankings.

That’s why it’s essential to think about how you generate links to your site.

As Matt Cutts says, links shouldn’t just LOOK natural, they should BE natural.

To achieve that, you need to identify and eliminate unhealthy links. Here’s how you do that.

Analyze links: First, analyze inbound links to your site. There are several link analysis tools you can use to do this, including:

Let me walk you through a link analysis using Open Link Profiler.

Go to the homepage and type in your URL. Let’s use

Now click “Analyze backlinks.”

The results show the most important elements to look for when analyzing your backlinks, including:

  • Unique Active Backlinks – This shows the number of links that directly or indirectly affect your Google ranking. “Unique” means that the links are from different IP addresses… that’s one way to identify a natural link. These links have been indexed by Google in the last 90 days.
  • Nofollow links Problogger has 8.3% nofollow links, which equals 1,684 backlinks from the total of 20,293. Google introduced the rel= “nofollow” tag in 2005 to stop spammy blog comments from artificially manipulating rankings. After the Google Penguin update was rolled out, it became essential to diversify your link profile. And as Matt Cutts mentioned, you need a mix of dofollow links (links that pass ranking value to search engines) and nofollow links (links that don’t pass ranking value).
  • Industry – If you read the content of Problogger, you might think that its industry is “blogging” or “internet marketing.” But, when you look at this analysis, it turns out to be “media.” Knowing your industry can help you identify relevant links that will improve your backlink profile in the search algorithm used by the search engine.
  • Link Influence Score – This shows how links from the website influence the search engine rankings of linked pages. The higher the LIS the better. As a very popular and influential site, Problogger’s score is a whopping 99%! Check your own site and see what your LIS is.
  • Anchor text Click on the link in the left menu to access data for anchor text (anchor text is the text that becomes your link and points to your page) linking into your site. Google’s Penguin update was rolled out to prevent site owners from manipulating search results with exact match anchor text. If you want to stay under the search algorithm penalty radar, diversify your anchor text.

It is also important to know which links are healthy for your site so that you can remove unhealthy links. Google Penguin 2.0 made it much easier to identify low-quality links. Those are links that:

  • come from PR-n/a or PR0 websites
  • are mostly sitewide links
  • are from referring domain names with little traffic
  • come from sites on the same IP class address
  • comes from web pages with a lot of external links

There are many free tools to help you identify unhealthy links. Two that I’ve tried include Monitor Backlinks and Linkquidator. Here’s how to check for unhealthy links with Monitor Backlinks.

Simply type in your site URL and click “search” to find unnatural links. Moz has a detailed tutorial on which links can harm your site and what to do about it. Remember that you also have to export the list of unhealthy links once you find them. That way, you can refer to them later.


When you discover spammy links pointing to your page, don’t be in a rush to remove the page itself. It’s the links that you need to remove so the search algorithm doesn’t penalize you.


That’s the next step in cleaning up your link profile and there are two ways to do it.

1. Request manual link removal – Visit the website where the unhealthy/unnatural links are coming from and contact the site owner. Ask the site owner to either remove your link (the better option) or add a nofollow tag to it.

If you have outsourced link building in the past, you can also contact the person who placed the links for you and have that person to get the links removed. Here’s an excerpt from a post at Search Engine World to show how this would work:

In this case, don’t ask the site owner to remove your links because they will assume you’re a spammer and ignore you. Instead, follow this tutorial from Search Engine Journal to learn the best way to contact webmasters about link removal.

2. Use Google’s disavow links tool – If you are unsuccessful in getting unhealthy links removed, your only option is Google’s own disavow links tool. While manual link removal is best, this is a good second choice.

The disavow links tool is part of Google Webmaster Tools. Click the link above to go directly to the tool. You will see a list of all of your sites. Go to the site for which you want to disavow links. This is what you will see:

When you check for unnatural links, you have the option to export the links that you find. If you have done this, upload the file and click “done.”

Like you, Google cannot actually remove the links as they don’t have access to the referring sites.

However, doing this authorizes Google to stop passing link juice (value) from those links to your page content.

3. Diversify anchor text distribution – Anchor text can play a key role in improving or utterly destroying your search ranking. As I mentioned earlier, if you want a natural link profile, you have to diversify anchor text.

Anchor text distribution looks at how you spread keywords when building links. The chart below has some recommendations:

When distributing your anchor text, think about including these types:

Let’s assume your page content sells blue denim jeans. If your domain name is, how do you distribute your anchor text?

If you want to link three times from a particular site, it’s ideal to use this link profile:

  • Anchor text 1: site – target page: homepage
  • Anchor text 2: denim jeans reviews online – target page: a page where you reviewed the item
  • Anchor text 3: reviews – target page: your store

4. Avoid over-optimization – When you overuse anchor texts, it can result in over-optimization and can get you penalized. Geoff Kenyon suggests the percentage below:

To avoid over-optimization, follow these two guidelines:

  1. Avoid excessively keyword-rich anchor text If you want to link to your internal pages on a topic, like “link building strategies,” don’t use that same keyword phrase as your anchor text. Instead, vary it and use something like “learn more about link building” or a combination of a generic plus the exact keyword.
  2. Avoid irrelevant links What’s the point of linking to your dog training site, using “best golf trainer” as your anchor? It doesn’t make sense to improve Google rankings and could actually result in a Google penalty.

If you need a detailed guide on over-optimization, see How to Avoid Over Optimization For your Site.

Step #4: Do Keyword Research

When you have gotten rid of unnatural links, it’s time to improve on-page SEO the right way. One essential element of an effective inbound marketing strategy is keyword research. You won’t get far in your online business without understanding how it works.

Learn how your audience finds your site: To be effective, you need to pinpoint the keywords that your target audience is using to find your site. Here’s how that works.

Log into your Google account and visit Google Keywords Planner.

On the dashboard, click “search for new keyword and ad group ideas.”

Now, input your primary keyword. Let’s use html tutorials

After clicking on the “keywords” tab, the table shows your keywords and their respective search volume for the month:

Here’s how that helps you.

When you research keywords, you’re getting firsthand information about your target audience, the information that they want to know and how they want it.

For example, when someone searches for “html5 tutorials for beginners,” you know that the searcher is a newbie who might have searched extensively for solutions and wants page content to help with this topic.

That can guide you in writing headlines and content that will rank well in the Google search results.

It’s helpful to figure out the buyer personas and customer life cycle of your target audience, so that you understand what motivates them. Then, you can provide relevant page content that will help your improve Google rankings.

Alexa can help you work out audience demographics, as in the example below for Upworthy.

Remember when I earlier mentioned commercial and informational keywords? When you do keyword research, you can easily figure out whether users are looking for information or wanting to buy.

That’s called user intent and here’s how it looks for the keyword research example used earlier.

You need both informational and commercial keywords in your page content to improve Google rankings of your website.

Commercial keywords target buyers who have been pre-sold (educated on the product) before coming to Google to conduct a search. Informational keywords build on-going rapport with those who are not yet buyers/customers.

It’s your job to educate, inform, inspire, and build interest before recommending a product. Informational keywords can be used to build email lists and nurture prospects before offering a product for sale.

When doing keyword research, don’t ignore long-tail keywords. Rand Fishkin of Moz shows how targeting long-tail keywords produced an 80% increase in traffic & improve Google rankings.

Spy on competitors: If your competitors are ranking ahead of you in Google search results, it’s time to spy on them.

If the search algorithm likes them, you can learn and copy them. I like to use Google Keyword Planner for this because it gives me an accurate estimate of competitors’ keyword targets.

Let’s assume you’re in the “survival knife” sub-niche. One of the authority blogs that you can spy on is

On the homepage, instead of inputting a seed keyword, simply type your competitor’s URL into the landing page box, then scroll down and click “get ideas.”  Next, click the “keyword ideas” tab.

You will see the keywords that your competitor is targeting.

This works for any niche and can help you uncover hidden keywords that will help you improve your ranking.

Boost lower ranking keywords: If you find your web page on page 2, how can you boost its ranking to the front page of Google?

You can use the skyscraper method, popularized by Brian Dean from Backlinko. Find a post or article that’s ranking already, improve it and promote it everywhere. This led to a 457% organic traffic increase for him.

If you want to do this for your topic (for example, “outsourcing guide for small business”), follow this simple guide:

  • Research extensively on the topic, including research studies.
  • Identify the keywords that you can target using the strategies that I’ve shared with you in this post.
  • Write a more in-depth post (that’s longer, more accurate and actionable).
  • Link out to authority blogs that are doing outsourcing well.

It’s also essential to write a powerful and clickable headline.

For example, if your first headline is:

Outsourcing Guide For Small Business

You can improve it like this:

6-Step Outsourcing Guide For Small Business

The Ultimate Outsourcing Guide + Downloadable Free Report

Contact the blog owners that you mentioned in your post and ask them to check it out. Hopefully, you’ll get a handful of authority sites to link back to you, hopefully, to improve Google rankings on your page content.

Use keyword analysis to improve content: Let’s get one thing straight. There is no optimal ratio for placing keywords in a piece of content.

However, knowing the right keywords to target is of utmost importance. That’s the basis for keyword analysis.

Wordstream defines keyword analysis as:

Keyword analysis is the starting point and cornerstone of search marketing campaigns. By understanding what queries qualified visitors to your website type into search engines, search marketers can better customize their landing pages to increase conversion rates.

Unless you know the queries that qualified visitors type into Google, you’ll find it difficult to improve your ranking and conversion rates.

By now, you know how to do keyword search engine research. That’s the easy part. The difficult part is knowing which keywords are bringing in organic traffic.

Earlier, I walked you through the process of generating the best keywords using Serp Scan. Now, we’re looking at the results to find the real keywords that people type into Google before your web page shows up.

You can use these to write on-page SEO content that matches user intent (remember that?). This will improve Google rankings for your web page.

How should you place your target keywords in the content? Let’s assume you want to write an in-depth review on, “best senior irons for seniors.” Here are some titles that you could use:

  • Top 10 Best Senior Irons For Seniors
  • Buyers’ Guide For The Best Senior Irons For Seniors
  • Best Senior Irons For Seniors – The Ultimate Guide

To start your introduction, you could begin like this:

There are several senior irons in the marketplace. But knowing the right one for you is the most difficult decision. If you read this guide from start to finish, you’ll know the best senior irons for seniors that are affordable and reliable.

Or, you could start your introduction by asking a question:

Do you want to find the best senior irons for seniors? This page will not just tell you about the irons but will show how to use them to improve your golf game and provide practical tips on getting a huge discount for your purchase.

Do you see how I placed the target keyword in the first paragraph, without making it seem like spam?

As I’ve said before, target a specific keyword in a natural manner – don’t try to make it look natural.

Step #5:  Go After Your Keywords with Great Content

Although I’ve touched a bit on keyword placement, in this section, we’ll look more at going after the keywords that you have researched.

Sadly, a lot of people have misunderstood the whole essence of keyword research and placement. Even before Google rolled out their first Google Panda update, in February 2011, the best search marketers knew that quality, valuable and useful content should be aimed at a particular group of people. 

Optimize for informational keywords and improve your search ranking by writing resourceful and detailed content and supplementing with descriptive meta description and title tags. That will help attract raving fans, get your content shared on social media platforms and garner relevant and high PR links naturally.

If you want to write resourceful and detailed content, follow the guide below:

Use data-driven articles: A data-driven approach can increase your traffic, says ConversionXL. Back up facts with accurate data, so that people will see your content as authoritative and want to share it on social media, expanding your organic reach. This post on how to create and promote an infographic is an example of data-driven content.

Other examples of data-driven content include:

The Simple Science of Getting More Done (with Less Time)
5 Things You’re Measuring Incorrectly with Digital Analytics and What To Do About It
7 Proven Strategies To Increase Your Blog’s Traffic By 206%

The resources below will help you to back up your content with accurate data:

Hubspot Marketing Statistics You Need To Know
The Freelance Economy in Numbers
Over 100 B2B Content Marketing Statistics For 2014
20 Social Media Facts and Statistics
Statistics: Release Calendar

Techniques to try include experimenting and writing case studies for your audience or expanding on what others have done. You can even micro-target content. For example, if a blogger experiments with niche marketing, take it a step further and try niche marketing with an aged domain name, then write it up.

Use storytelling: Stories can captivate your audience, evoke emotions and improve your conversion rate.

Alibaba’s China story, which centered on their passion for trading, helped them grow into a multi-billion dollar ecommerce company.

Here’s how to tell a story that captivates your audience…

Begin with something unique: Harvard Business School recommends that you start with a unique message that resonates with your audience. Ideally, this should connect with your audience’s questions.

Infuse your own experiences: It’s called a story for a good reason. Use your own experiences (whether good or bad) as part of the message. No fakery allowed!

Jon Morrow used this on-page seo page content technique to grow his blog to 1,740 loyal subscribers in just seven days. Here’s the post that helped him connect with his audience: How To Quit Your Job, Move To Paradise and Get Paid To Change The World.

Add a call-to-action (CTA): Every story must have an ending. Once you capture your readers’ attention, they will expect you to let them in on the solution. After all, your story is supposed to solve a problem, not nurture it.

Use a call-to-action link or button to lead people to your funnel and convert them. Matchoffice increased its conversion rate by 14.79% by changing its CTA copy.

Write sharable headlines: Google has made a lot of changes to search rankings, but one element remains crucial: the headline.

If you write a sharable headline for your post, nothing can stop it from getting clicked, read and shared by true fans.

Peep Laja of ConversionXL increased his conversion rate by changing the word “today” to “now” in a headline. And, that helped him increase sales by 332%.

Headlines really win the clicks. Even if your web page is ranked at #1 in Google for page content, that doesn’t mean that you’ll get the most clicks. On-page SEO gets you in the running but the title may lead the clicks. Let’s search for the term how to outsource. Note that the most clickable headline is in position #2.

The perfect example of a website that uses sharable headlines to boost conversion rate is Upworthy. I’ve used Buzzsumo to analyze Upworthy’s headlines. Check out the amazing number of shares the first article has racked up.

If I wanted to craft a better headline for my own content, here’s what I’d do:

Add numbers: Upworthy’s post was shared over 1.6 million times on Facebook, because it has a definite number. If the headline was “Americans are Completely Wrong About This Mind-Blowing Fact,” I’m sure that the total number of social media shares would be lower.

Here are some more examples. When I wrote this post, these headlines were ranked in the Google top 10 for their respective keywords.  But, a simple tweak would result in a higher click-through rate.

Original headline:

SEO Basics For Optimizing Your Site

Let’s add some numbers:

  • 6 SEO Basic Tips For Optimizing Your Site
  • 12 SEO Basics You Need To Optimize Your Site

Original headline:

  • Freelance Writing Tips For Stay-at-Home Moms
  • Freelance Writing Jobs To Make Money

Let’s add some numbers

  • 5 Freelance Writing Tips To Help Stay at Home Moms Make Money
  • 10 Freelance Writing Jobs You Can Make Money From

Invoke curiosity: Curiosity will cause people to click your headline, but do it with caution and make sure that you deliver on the promise of your headline with quality page content.

For example, if your title is:

Top 7 Body Building Secrets You Didn’t Know

Then make sure that you reveal the ‘7’ secrets and ideally what you reveal needs to new or unique. Here are a couple more examples of sharable headlines that invoke curiosity:

Once you have great on-page SEO content that includes informational or commercial keywords and tells a story that appeals to your audience, it’s time to build links the right way for improving Google rankings.

Step #6: Build Links the Right Way

Earlier, I showed you how to analyze links to your site using Open Link Profiler. Here’s another analysis I did for the Businessweek site.

Note that it shows a range of different types of anchor text for inbound links. That’s exactly what you need to build links the right way. Here are some of the ways to do that and the types of links that you need.

Anchor text linking (in-text links): Anchor text links are simple links that appear within the content. See an example below…

I discovered that when you place anchor text links “above-the-fold,” it can increase conversion rates.

The anchor text linking strategy is mostly used when you’re looking to rank for a particular keyword. You can use your target keyword as anchor text, but to be on the safe side and avoid penalties with the search algorithm, mix it up with generic keywords.

For example, if your primary keyword is digital camera reviews, when building your links from another site, link naturally like this: find the best digital camera reviews, top digital camera brands, etc. A good mix is smart on-page SEO.

Image links: You can also use images to build links when you write posts or guest posts. Here’s how you do that in WordPress. When you are ready to add an image to a post, type the keyword that you would like to use as your anchor text in the “Alt Text” box. Images are indexed by Google and that means you will get a link back to your site.

Editorial links: If you follow this SEO guide, you should be able to create useful and sharable content through social media that will naturally result in valuable inbound links. A good example is the post on 200 ranking factors that Brian Dean wrote.  It’s been cited multiple times.

For Google, what other people say about you is much more important and relevant than what you say yourself to improve Google rankings.

Over the years, I have created thousands of rich, data-driven and useful blog page content.  If you search for anything related to content marketing, Quick Sprout pops up, which means that I get a lot of editorial links.

Copyblogger links out to useful and relevant resource posts that contribute to the engagement that they already have with their audience.

I strongly believe that the site owners didn’t do anything to get those editorial links. They simply earned the links because of the usefulness of their content. Focus on exceptional content, if you want to earn links that will improve the rank of your web pages.

Scale link building: Link diversity is the ultimate way to generate Google-friendly links and improve Google rankings, while staying off the penalty radar. This complete tutorial from Chris Liversidge will show you how to scale your link building to benefit in the search algorithm.

Old techniques, like directory submission, forum marketing, wiki sites and even guest blogging and press releases don’t work as well as they did in the past. To get a diverse inbound link profile, write page content that will gain links from local, regional and international sites relevant to your own. Then, you’ll build a natural link profile, with natural, targeted on-page SEO that will withstand anything Google throws at it.